Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

InMyArea.com earns commissions from some of the providers we list on our site. Learn more  

Best Internet Providers in Middle Island, NY

Search by Zip Code

Top 6 Internet Service Providers in Middle Island, NY

Filter by:
Sort by:

1. AT&T

28.6% Available
Download speeds up to:
225 Mbps 5G Internet
Prices Starting At 60.00/mo *
28.6% Available

2. Optimum

11% Available
Download speeds up to:
5 Gbps Cable, Fiber
Prices Starting At 40.00/mo
11% Available

3. EarthLink

35.7% Available
Download speeds up to:
100 Mbps 5G Internet
Prices Starting At 39.95/mo
35.7% Available

4. HughesNet

100% Available
Download speeds up to:
100 Mbps Satellite
Prices Starting At 49.99/mo
100% Available

5. Starlink

100% Available
Download speeds from:
50 - 220 Mbps Satellite
Prices Starting At 120.00/mo
100% Available

6. Always ON

35.7% Available
Download speeds from:
25 - 150 Mbps Fixed Wireless
35.7% Available

Best Internet Providers in Middle Island

When it comes to finding the best internet in Middle Island, NY, it's all about finding the right balance between speed and budget—and maybe which provider has a great hold music (just kidding, kind of).

First up, let's talk fiber. If you've got the need for speed, the fiber option from Optimum should be on the top of your shopping list. With a whopping max download speed of 5 Gbps, it's perfect for anyone who's ever tried to stream in HD, download a giant file, and host a Zoom meeting all at the same time. Just think of it as the Olympic gold medalist of internet options—it’ll make your devices run like Usain Bolt, for only $40 a month!

If fiber isn't available in your neck of the woods (it covers roughly 7.1% of the area), don't worry—cable internet struts in like a solid runner-up. Optimum also provides cable internet with impressive speeds up to 940 Mbps. This connection is super reliable and covers 11% of Middle Island, making it an awesome fit for busy households. It's like fiber's trusty sidekick, ready to tackle all your browsing, streaming, and gaming needs for $40 a month.

Now, maybe you enjoy keeping your options open. If that's the case, consider giving 5G home internet a whirl. EarthLink's 5G Home Internet comes with a space-age twist at just $39.95 a month. With a download speed of up to 100 Mbps and 35.7% coverage, it's perfect for binge-watchers and work-from-home warriors alike.

So, whether you're zooming through the digital landscape with fiber, coasting comfortably on cable, or embracing the future with 5G, Middle Island has an internet option that'll tune in perfectly to your bandwidth expectations.

Internet Provider Store Locations in Middle Island

Compare Internet Providers in Nearby Cities:

Coram, Medford, Miller Place, Mount Sinai, Ridge, Rocky Point, Selden, Shoreham, Sound Beach, Yaphank

Average download speed in Middle Island:

118 Mbps

Based on 6,170 speed tests

Best Internet Provider in Middle Island

  1. AT&T - 5g internet up to 225 Mbps
  2. Optimum - Fast download speeds in Middle Island, most Fiber availability and most Cable availability
  3. EarthLink - 5g internet up to 100 Mbps
  4. HughesNet - Another great satellite internet alternative for those who can't get Cable, Fiber, or DSL
  5. Starlink - Most internet coverage in Middle Island
  6. Always ON - Fixed wireless up to 150 Mbps

Fastest Internet Providers in Middle Island

  • Optimum - Fast up to 5 Gbps (5000 Mbps)
  • AT&T - Fast up to 225 Mbps
  • Starlink - Fast up to 220 Mbps
  • Always ON - Fast up to 150 Mbps

How Much Speed Do I Need?

25+ Mbps

  • Web Surfing & Email
  • HD Streaming
  • Supports 1-2 Devices
  • Ideal for 1-2 people

100+ Mbps

  • Ultra HD (4K) Streaming
  • Low Lag Online Gaming
  • Supports 3-5 Devices
  • Ideal for 2-6 people

1 Gig

  • Multi 4K HD Streaming
  • No Lag Online Gaming
  • Supports more than 5 Devices
  • Ideal for 6+ people

An Overview of Internet Providers in Middle Island By Connection

Provider Connection Download speeds up to Availability
Optimum Cable 940 Mbps 11%
HughesNet Satellite 100 Mbps 100%
AT&T 5G Internet 225 Mbps 29%
Optimum Fiber 8 Gbps 7%
Starlink Satellite 220 Mbps 100%
T-Mobile Home Internet 5G Internet 245 Mbps 8%
Verizon 5G Internet 300 Mbps 4%
EarthLink 5G Internet 100 Mbps 36%
Always ON Fixed Wireless 25 Mbps 36%
Provider Connection Download speeds up to Availability
HughesNet Satellite 100 Mbps 100%
Starlink Satellite 220 Mbps 100%
Optimum Cable 940 Mbps 11%
Optimum Fiber 5 Gbps 7%
T-Mobile Home Internet 5G Internet 100 Mbps 8%
Verizon 5G Internet 50 Mbps 4%
AT&T 5G Internet 225 Mbps 29%

Popular Zip Codes in Middle Island, NY:

Internet Availability by Connection Type in Middle Island

Internet service providers in Middle Island use different methods for connecting their customers to the web. Connection types matter, so choose wisely. Fiber is generally the fastest and most reliable option, followed by cable, DSL and 5G home internet.

Fiber - 95%

What is Mbps?

Mbps is the abbreviation for megabits per second, and it also appears written as Mbits/sec. Internet providers use megabits per second to measure speeds. Broadband speeds are 25 Mbps or faster. Learn more about Mbps.

Who is InMyArea.com?

InMyArea.com is a 5 star rated internet service provider comparison and home services website. Read more about InMyArea.com.

Looking for some local deals or unhappy with your current internet provider?

Call one of our experts waiting to help you find the right provider!